Tile roofs are often admired for their beauty and longevity, but they’re also surrounded by a surprising number of misconceptions. These roofing systems have been trusted for centuries, yet many homeowners hesitate to choose tile due to outdated information or misunderstandings. At Robinson Roofing KC, we’ve seen it all—and we’re here to set the record straight.
Whether you’re considering a new tile roof or just want to better understand the material above your head, this guide breaks down the most common tile roof myths and provides the real facts. Understanding the truth about tile roofing will help you make smarter decisions for your property.
Myth #1: Tile Roofs Are Too Heavy for Most Homes
The Reality: While tile roofs are heavier than asphalt shingles, most modern homes—and even many older ones—can support tile with little to no structural adjustment. Before any installation, our team at Robinson Roofing KC conducts a thorough inspection to determine if reinforcement is needed.
Today’s tile options include lighter alternatives like synthetic tiles, which mimic the look of traditional clay or slate without the weight. Concrete tiles also come in varying thicknesses, giving homeowners more flexibility in choosing a material that suits their structure.
According to the U.S. Department of Energy, tile roofing materials can help reflect more sunlight and reduce roof surface temperatures, making them not just practical, but energy-efficient—even with added weight.
Myth #2: Tile Roofs Only Work in Warm Climates
The Reality: This is one of the most persistent tile roof myths. While it’s true that tile performs exceptionally well in hot, dry environments, tile roofs are just as effective in cold and storm-prone climates—like Kansas City.
Clay, concrete, and slate tiles can withstand snow, ice, and freezing temperatures without degrading. They’re also naturally resistant to freeze-thaw cycles because of their density and moisture-shedding capabilities.
For cold climates, it’s important that the tile is installed with proper underlayment and ventilation. Our experienced crew ensures your roof is protected from moisture buildup, ice dams, and other winter-related issues.
Myth #3: Tile Roofs Break Easily
The Reality: Yes, roof tiles can crack under direct impact—such as a heavy tree limb falling on them—but under normal conditions, tile is one of the most durable roofing materials available.
Most tile roofs resist hail, wind, and even fire better than asphalt shingles. The key is in proper installation and regular maintenance. Our GAF-certified roofing specialists at Robinson Roofing KC use high-quality materials and time-tested techniques to minimize breakage risks from the start.
According to the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), well-installed clay and concrete tiles offer excellent wind uplift resistance when installed according to code.
If a tile does break, replacing individual pieces is straightforward—far easier than replacing large sections of other roofing types.
Myth #4: Tile Roofs Are Outdated or Old-Fashioned
The Reality: Tile roofs have been around for thousands of years, but that doesn’t make them outdated. In fact, modern tile roofing options include contemporary designs that suit everything from classic Spanish-style homes to modern urban residences.
Flat concrete tiles, interlocking designs, and synthetic materials now give homeowners a sleek, minimalistic option that still delivers on strength and weather protection. You’re not limited to terracotta or barrel tiles—tile roofing has evolved in design as much as it has in technology.
Tile is also highly customizable. You can choose from a wide variety of colors, finishes, and profiles to suit your home’s architectural style. At Robinson Roofing KC, we help clients choose tile designs that match their vision and stand up to local weather.
Myth #5: Tile Roofs Are Too Expensive
The Reality: While tile roofs have a higher upfront cost compared to asphalt shingles, they offer far better long-term value. With a lifespan of 50 to 100 years or more, tile outlasts nearly every other roofing option on the market.
Asphalt shingles may need replacing every 15–25 years, while tile requires less frequent repairs and replacements. The durability of clay, concrete, or slate reduces lifecycle costs dramatically, especially when installed by experienced professionals.
Homeowners also benefit from lower insurance premiums in some cases because tile is naturally fire-resistant and storm-tough. These savings can add up over time, making tile more affordable than it might first appear.
Myth #6: Tile Roofs Require Constant Maintenance
The Reality: Compared to other roofing types, tile roofs are actually low-maintenance. Most issues—such as cracked tiles or debris buildup—can be resolved quickly without impacting the overall integrity of the roof.
At Robinson Roofing KC, we recommend a roof inspection every couple of years to identify minor issues before they turn into bigger ones. With simple maintenance like cleaning out gutters, removing moss, and replacing any cracked tiles, your tile roof can remain in excellent condition for decades.
The underlayment is often the first component to wear out on a tile roof, but replacing underlayment is significantly less costly than re-roofing with new materials.
Myth #7: Installing Tile Roofs Takes Too Long
The Reality: Installing a tile roof can take longer than asphalt, but not by much—especially when done by experienced professionals. At Robinson Roofing KC, we’ve fine-tuned our tile installation process to be both efficient and precise.
Our team handles:
- Site preparation
- Structural assessment
- Waterproof underlayment installation
- Tile layout planning and placement
The result is a timely installation that doesn’t sacrifice quality. Depending on the size and complexity of the project, most tile roofs can be installed in a few days to a week.
Myth #8: Tile Roofs Trap Heat
The Reality: Tile roofs are actually highly effective at keeping buildings cool. Thanks to the natural thermal properties of clay, slate, and concrete, these materials absorb and slowly release heat, reducing indoor temperature spikes during summer.
Additionally, the curved design of many tile styles promotes ventilation between the tiles and roof deck, helping prevent heat buildup. According to research from the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, certain tile roofs can reduce heat transfer by up to 70% compared to asphalt shingles.
This makes tile an energy-efficient option in both hot and variable climates. With the right underlayment and insulation, a tile roof can support better HVAC performance year-round.
Real Value Comes from the Right Roofing Partner
Tile roofs offer an unbeatable combination of style, longevity, and performance—but only if installed and maintained properly. That’s where Robinson Roofing KC comes in. With over 75 years of combined experience and locations across Kansas City, Sedalia, and Plano, we specialize in tile roof installation, repair, and storm damage restoration.
We work with a variety of tile materials:
- Clay tile
- Concrete tile
- Slate tile
- Synthetic tile
- Spanish and flat tile profiles
As a GAF-certified contractor, we provide roofing systems that come with 50-year warranties, ensuring your investment is protected. Our family-owned business values communication, craftsmanship, and long-term relationships with the communities we serve.
Ready to Replace Roofing Myths with Facts?
Don’t let outdated myths hold you back from choosing one of the most durable and beautiful roofing systems available. Whether you need help deciding on the right tile or want to inspect your current roof’s condition, we’ve got you covered.
Get a free inspection now and take the first step toward a stronger, longer-lasting roof backed by proven performance and expert care.
Let Robinson Roofing KC bring the truth—and the tile—to your roof.
